I hear ya on that, SWL. I genuinely feel a detachment from games these days and for a while, I trying to get my friends to try out some boardgames and pen and paper stuff. Something I've never really ever done but I felt myself wanting something a little more... old fashioned? Is that the term? There was a time where I was just crazy about games. I mastered all the finishing moves on Mortal Kombat II, all the secrets, etc. Completed Final Fantasy III (VI) 100% on the SNES, got Cid the healthy fish to make sure he survived, etc.
I don't know if it's that there's just so much variety, it's a little overwhelming. None of it feels special anymore.
Also, the gameplay has evolved significantly in many of my old favourites like Silent Hill, Resident Evil, etc. I loved the gameplay of the old Resident Evil games as awkward as they were, it worked for what it was. When 4 rolled around, it was a huge change, but it was enjoyable. With 5, though and onward, the feel of the game and the mechanics had changed so drastically that it didn't even really feel like survival horror to me anymore. It started feeling like a mixture of a generic first person shooter combined with Dragon's Lair style minigames.
Sometimes I install really old games and try to beat them for the first time. A couple of years ago, I installed Baldur's Gate on a machine that I had XP on and beat it, then I installed Baldur's Gate II and came pretty close. I think I stopped around this part where you try to complete a quest that involved lizardmen. I was at the end of that part. Got sidetracked, but that was a lot of fun for me. I might give it another crack or Icewind Dale. Then maybe the Neverwinter games. Maybe Diablo after. lol. I tried to beat Starcraft 1 all the way through but it glitched during the Protoss missions (final missions)!
Last of Us looked bloody amazing, though, Bo-Rilla. Shame it's a PS3 exclusive.